Planning for Success: A CFO’s Guide to the Strategic Business Case
-
2025年11月06日
-
In today’s environment of heightened capital scrutiny and accelerated transformation, chief financial officers (“CFOs”) face mounting pressure to justify every investment and deliver measurable value. Whether establishing a new entity, launching a business unit or entering a new market, a strategic, data-driven business case is the CFO’s most powerful governance tool — aligning resources, driving accountability and setting the foundation for enterprise value creation.
When an executive team decides to establish a new entity or acquire a new stand-alone business unit, efficient and effective stand-up is paramount to enable timely achievement of goals — from realizing identified target value and reducing cost pressure, to accessing specialized talent or positioning for expansion.
In a case we recently outlined, where we helped our client, a $1 billion North American financial services company, successfully stand up a new operating model and business unit in Europe, the business case did more than justify investment — it drove clarity, accountability and post-go-live return on investment (“ROI”) realization. Developed with executive sponsorship and actively refined through to implementation, it served as a management tool that guided both decision-making and performance tracking.
The Importance of Business Cases
Business cases are critical in any strategic initiative but especially in stand-ups. Initially, a business case anchors decision-making, justifying investment and resource allocation, demonstrating ROI and value creation potential, and managing expectations about outcomes. During execution, a business case becomes an operational blueprint, setting clear objectives and timelines, defining decision rights and supporting change management — all of which drive alignment across stakeholder groups. Upon completion, the business case transitions into a measurable framework, enabling leaders to evaluate success, measure ROI and identify additional opportunities for long-term value capture.
Elements of a Strong Business Case
When preparing for a strategic initiative, certain key elements ensure the business plan is comprehensive, accurate and effective in driving outcomes.
It can be difficult to design, develop and maintain a business case that is proportionate to the initiative’s scope, scale and complexity. A “right-sized” plan eliminates unnecessary complexity and ensures that decision-makers have clear, actionable insight to accelerate decision-making — not excessive documentation.
At its core, a business case should combine robust financial analysis with strategic rationale, governance clarity and measurable performance indicators. To maximize its usefulness as both a planning and execution tool, define upfront how progress will be tracked, reported and refined through the lifecycle of the initiative.
For our client, the financial business case was strong, but there were also strategic benefits, which included sharpening focus on a high-growth business unit, enabling access to alternative capital markets outside of North America and co-locating with a strategic partner. Capturing these benefits within the business case enabled leadership to communicate the broader “why” to investors and employees alike.
Financial Analysis
The financial analysis outlines the operating model’s projected benefits, built up through changes to labor costs, non-labor costs and one-time investments, overlaid across an implementation timeline.
At first, estimates will be based on initial assumptions with best-case, worst-case and most-likely scenarios. As assumptions are validated, CFOs should update values, maintain version control and preserve range estimates in order to support contingency planning and transparent communication.
Labor Costs: In an operating model design, roles are added, redefined or eliminated to establish the future-state organization. Labor considerations include changes in employee cost, compensation assumptions (base salary, bonuses, fringe rates, salary increases, cost-of-living adjustments) and start or end dates for each role. For our client’s European stand-up, start dates were aligned in waves based on role priority and recruitment timelines, which, combined with parallel processing periods, helped to inform end dates and continuity planning.
Non-Labor Costs: A stand-up requires adjustments to operational expenses, property costs and professional fees. These may include insurance, banking, technology infrastructure, outsourcing, travel and real estate-related costs such as depreciation, property taxes and management fees. Ongoing professional services fees — such as legal, audit and payroll — should be recalibrated. In international stand-ups, recurring costs such as personal tax gross-ups or expatriate benefits should also be modeled to avoid post-launch cost surprises.
Restructuring Costs: One-time expenses meeting definitions set forth in the International Financial Reporting Standards or Generally Accepted Accounting Principles may include retention and severance, agency fees, lease terminations, site closures and consulting or legal costs directly linked to the program. Offering retention incentives to key employees ensures continuity of institutional knowledge and smoother transitions, all of which strengthens post-close performance.
Other One-Time Costs: Certain non-recurring costs, while not restructuring-related in nature, still require visibility. In our client’s European stand-up, market entry costs — such as relocation packages, visa fees, recruitment expenses and dual-running roles for knowledge transfer — were categorized separately in order to distinguish growth-related spend from transitional cost.
Timeline: To quantify the net present value or payback period, the team should define the implementation timeline based on project milestones, dependencies and risks.
Financial benefits should be quantified and tracked against baseline metrics. These often include labor savings from automation, process optimization or outsourcing, as well as operational and real estate efficiencies. CFOs should also assess jurisdictional incentives such as research and development credits, grants or tax advantages that enhance the business case.
Strategic Benefits
While the financial metrics are tangible, strategic benefits often drive the real value story. These may include market expansion, access to new talent pools, regulatory readiness, operational flexibility and improved competitive positioning.
Performance Indicators
Defining key performance indicators (“KPIs”) to measure progress and post-go-live success is critical. Without a disciplined measurement framework, even the strongest business case can lose credibility.
During implementation, closely track recruitment and onboarding timelines, as delays erode ROI through extended dual-payroll costs. Post go-live, track total costs and realized benefits against the plan. Using KPIs to monitor performance will enable CFOs to recalibrate assumptions early, safeguard value realization and right-size operations once the new organization stabilizes.
Established Responsibilities and Processes
While advisors may drive creation of the business case, ownership must reside within the organization. Someone with the capability and capacity to manage it — often a financial business partner or financial planning and analysis lead — should be accountable for maintaining assumptions, tracking realization and reporting to leadership.
In addition, the structure and presentation of the business case must enable quick interpretation and decision-making, highlight movements in actuals vs. targets and allow for drilldown analysis. This transparency builds trust among stakeholders and fosters a performance-driven culture.
Key Enablers of Success: Learnings From Our Use Case
In our work with the North American financial services company, success was driven by executive sponsorship, disciplined financial governance and proactive change management.
Executive sponsorship is nonnegotiable. With visible leadership support, the business case remains grounded in reality, and momentum is sustained through execution. Embedding finance as a critical driver, not just a validator, ensures accountability and alignment between strategic ambition and financial discipline.
When developed correctly and actively managed, a business case becomes more than a planning document — it is a living mechanism that guides discussion, measures outcomes and sustains value long after go-live.
関連するインサイト
Related Information
出版
2025年11月06日
主な連絡先
Senior Managing Director, Leader of Merger Integration & Carve-Outs
シニア・マネージング・ディレクター
マネージング・ディレクター
シニア・ディレクター