Behind the Scenes of Personalized Pricing
Understanding the Risks and Regulations Driving Personalized Pricing Decisions
-
November 20, 2026
-
Many businesses rely on programs to automate price setting for goods and services, typically in response to changing market conditions.1 The airline industry has used this practice, known as algorithmic pricing, to sell plane tickets since its deregulation in 1978.2 However, a specific form of algorithmic pricing, known as personalized or surveillance pricing, has attracted recent consumer and legislative attention.
Personalized pricing uses personal information to inform algorithms that tailor prices at the consumer level. This information can include location data, browsing and online behavior, purchase history, demographic information, consumer preferences, or contextual data such as time and purchasing channel.3 In practice, this means two consumers searching for the same item on their respective devices could see different prices.
As organizations employ increasingly sophisticated consumer data to drive individualized pricing decisions, it is imperative that they understand the privacy, security, and broader risks involved.
Accelerating Regulatory Activity
Lawmakers and regulators at the state and federal levels have begun scrutinizing the personalized pricing practices under their purview.
Federal Action
In August 2026, the Federal Trade Commission (“FTC”) announced it was seeking public comment on a proposed enforcement policy statement concerning personalized pricing. The proposed statement warned that undisclosed collection, use, or disclosure of personal data for this purpose may violate Section 5 of the FTC Act.4 Then, in October 2026, the FTC launched inquiries into the pricing and worker compensation methodologies of nine companies, requiring each company to describe how it uses rules to set prices and wages and whether those rules leverage personal information.5
State Action
Since 2025, four states have also taken action to regulate the use of personalized pricing. Notably, New Jersey is the only state that permits a private right of action against surveillance pricing, which increases litigation risk.
| State | Mandate | Date Effective |
|---|---|---|
| Connecticut6 | Prohibits retailers, including food establishments, from engaging in personalized pricing and requires disclosure of personalized pricing for industries where it is permissible. | Starting July 1, 2027 |
| Maryland7 | Prohibits food retailers and third-party delivery services from using personalized pricing to set higher prices for customers. | Since October 1, 2026 |
| New Jersey8 |
Classifies the use of personalized pricing for groceries and other food items as a violation of the New Jersey Consumer Fraud Act. Prohibits the use of electronic shelf labels that use technology employing personalized pricing and grants a private right of action against personalized pricing, permitting consumers to file civil suits. |
Starting August 1, 2027 |
| New York9 |
Requires businesses to disclose personalized pricing practices. An amendment to the law currently sits with the governor, which, if passed, will prohibit personalized pricing and ban the collection, use, retention, or sharing of personal data to facilitate personalized pricing.10 |
Since November 10, 2025 |
Key Considerations for Organizations
Organizations should not wait for a government inquiry, consumer lawsuit, or new regulation to understand whether their existing security, privacy, and risk management processes adequately address applicable regulations. It is also imperative to identify what personal information is collected from consumers and if their pricing models ingest and use personal information.
Many departments beyond privacy and engineering influence algorithmic pricing decisions. Ensure that legal, marketing, sales, and product teams are involved in compliance discussions, understand their responsibilities, and embed appropriate safeguards into their processes.
Security, Privacy and Risk Management Processes
- Identify the privacy, consumer protection, and pricing-related laws and regulations that apply in each jurisdiction where the organization operates.
- Perform a comprehensive privacy maturity assessment to bring clarity, direction, and actionable intelligence to the organization’s compliance program.
- Assess current risks through policy review and stakeholder engagement, identify gaps between existing security, privacy, and risk management processes and applicable requirements, and develop a prioritized remediation roadmap.
Personal Information Collection
- Evaluate the consumer information the organization collects and catalog the data elements that constitute personal information, including sensitive personal information and any inferences or profiles derived about consumers.
- For each record, document the information’s provenance, data type, purpose of collection, location, shared access rights, and any downstream disclosure or data transfer that occurs.
- Confirm that collection practices align with the organization’s privacy notices and consent obligations, and that only the personal information necessary for stated purposes is collected and retained.
Ingesting and Using Personal Information
- Develop a living, actionable data flow diagram for each pricing model, from ingestion through output and downstream use, that identifies which inputs constitute personal information and serves as a foundation for privacy compliance, cybersecurity resilience, and artificial intelligence governance.
- Document data extractions, transformations, and any anonymization or de-identification.
- Identify model outputs and whether the results are shared with third parties or transferred to other jurisdictions.
- Review each algorithm’s logic or apply model-explainability techniques to understand how inputs, particularly personal information, drive pricing results, and test outputs for unintended pricing disparities across consumer groups.
Preparing for What’s Next
To ensure future personalized pricing models are evaluated appropriately, organizations should update processing activity assessment or privacy impact assessment templates to include questions regarding algorithmic pricing. Any pricing model using personal information should be classified as high-risk and reviewed and approved by the appropriate teams prior to launch. These assessments should evaluate how underlying datasets are used and protected, how prices are informed by the datasets, and whether the algorithm creates the potential for pricing biases.
Organizations that understand now what personal information drives their pricing models will be prepared for new regulatory requirements, with a compliant and defensible algorithmic pricing strategy built on high visibility, clear documentation, and strengthened consumer trust.
Footnotes:
1: Spann, Martin, et al., “Algorithmic Pricing: Implications for Marketing Strategy and Regulation,” NBER Working Paper 32540 (rev. June 2025).
2: McAfee, R. Preston and te Velde, Vera, “Dynamic Pricing in the Airline Industry,” Economics and Information Systems (2007), Microsoft Word - Dynamic paper.doc.
3: Fed. Trade Comm’n, “FTC Surveillance Pricing Study Indicates Wide Range of Personal Data Used to Set Individualized Consumer Prices,” (Jan. 17, 2025).
4: Fed. Trade Comm’n, “Federal Trade Commission’s Proposed Enforcement Policy Statement Regarding Personalized Pricing,” Docket No. FTC-2026-1057 (Aug. 19, 2026).
5: Fed. Trade Comm’n, “FTC Launches Personalized Pricing and Compensation Inquiry,” (Oct. 28, 2026).
6: Connecticut General Assembly, “An Act Concerning Consumer Privacy and Protection,” Public Act No. 26-64 (May 27, 2026).
7: Maryland General Assembly, “Food Retailers and Third-Party Delivery Service Providers - Dynamic Pricing and Personal Data (Protection From Predatory Pricing Act),” HB0895 (Jun. 30, 2026).
8: New Jersey Legislature, “Fair Price Protection Act,” Bill A4085 (March 19, 2026).
9: The New York State Senate, “Protection From Unfair, Deceptive, or Abusive Acts and Practices,” Article 22-A Section 349-A (July 11, 2025).
10: The New York State Senate, “An Act to Amend the General Business Law, in Relation to Prohibiting the Use of Surveillance Pricing,” Senate Bill S8623B (Jun. 5, 2026).
The views expressed herein are those of the author(s) and not necessarily the views of FTI Consulting, Inc., its management, its subsidiaries, its affiliates, or its other professionals.
Related Insights
Related Information
Published
November 20, 2026
Key Contacts
Senior Managing Director
Senior Managing Director
Director